Serviced accommodation vs Airbnb: a real estate investor’s guide to short-term rental success

Short-term rentals continue to attract real estate investors seeking flexible income streams and high returns. Two key models dominate this market: serviced accommodation and Airbnb listings. While both options involve renting furnished properties to short-stay guests, they operate under very different structures. These differences have serious implications for those looking to maximise profitability, manage risk, and reduce operational burden.

This guide breaks down each model from an investor’s perspective, helping you choose the right strategy based on your goals.

---

What is serviced accommodation?

Serviced accommodation refers to fully furnished units designed for short to mid-term stays. These properties are professionally managed, often by specialised operators, and cater to corporate clients, relocating professionals, and families in transition.

Key features include:

• Regular housekeeping and linen services

• High-speed internet and utilities included

• Guest support and maintenance services

• Standardised quality across units

These properties tend to be located in central business hubs or residential zones close to commercial demand, which drives consistent occupancy and attracts high-value guests.

Read more: A serviced accommodation guide

 

---

What is Airbnb?

Airbnb is a platform that connects property owners with people looking for short-term lodging. Hosts range from individual homeowners renting out spare rooms to full-time investors managing multiple listings. Airbnb properties vary greatly in quality and service standards.

Some provide hotel-like experiences, while others offer more casual or home-like settings. The platform handles booking, payments, and basic customer support, but much of the guest experience depends on the individual host.

Read more: Our complete guide on how to let on Airbnb

---

Key differences for real estate investors

1. Operational management

Serviced accommodation is run by professional operators who oversee every aspect of the guest experience. This includes bookings, check-ins, cleaning, and maintenance. For property owners, this translates into a passive income model with minimal daily involvement.

Airbnb hosting, unless outsourced, is hands-on. You must handle guest messaging, cleaning coordination, supply restocking, and review management. This workload can grow rapidly if managing multiple units.

Bottom line: Serviced accommodation reduces your operational overhead significantly.

2. Income predictability

Serviced accommodation typically delivers more stable income due to longer stays and corporate partnerships. Operators secure repeat bookings and negotiate with relocation firms or companies directly, which minimises vacancy.

Airbnb allows for dynamic pricing, which can yield higher nightly rates during peak seasons. However, income can fluctuate due to seasonality, local events, and competition.

Bottom line: Airbnb may offer higher peaks, but serviced accommodation brings more reliable monthly cash flow.

3. Compliance and regulation

Many cities now impose strict rules on short-term rentals. Airbnb hosts are often required to register their properties, follow zoning laws, and meet safety standards. Non-compliance can result in fines or restrictions.

Professional serviced accommodation providers typically operate under long-stay or corporate housing regulations, which are often more favourable. They also handle compliance, insurance, and safety protocols on behalf of the property owner.

Bottom line: Letting a professional operator handle legal compliance lowers your risk profile.

4. Guest expectations and experience

Guests choosing serviced accommodation expect hotel-like service, including cleanliness, responsiveness, and amenities. These properties are marketed with consistency in mind, which leads to high review scores and return bookings.

Airbnb experiences vary by host. While some provide excellent stays, others may fall short on quality or reliability. This variability can affect occupancy and repeat business.

Bottom line: Consistent quality attracts repeat corporate clients and improves occupancy rates.

5. Length of stay and occupancy strategy

Serviced accommodation targets stays of one week to several months. This longer average length of stay leads to reduced turnover costs and fewer gaps between bookings.

Airbnb caters to shorter stays, from one night onward. This means higher turnover, increased cleaning frequency, and the potential for inconsistent occupancy patterns.

Bottom line: Longer stays from serviced accommodation lead to lower operating costs and smoother operations.

---

Comparative overview

For investors

Aspect	Serviced Accommodation	Airbnb
Time Involvement	Low (outsourced)	High unless outsourced
Income Stability	Medium to High	Variable
Revenue Potential	Steady, with fewer gaps	High in peak seasons
Risk Level	Lower (compliance handled)	Higher (owner liable)
Scalability	Easier with third-party operator	Difficult without full-time management

 

For guests

Aspect	Serviced Accommodation	Airbnb
Cleanliness	Professionally maintained	Depends on host
Guest Support	24/7, professional	Often limited
Amenities	Full standard package	Varies by listing
Consistency	High	Inconsistent

 

---